The disclosure protocol

Journals and funders can differ widely in what they consider a conflict of interest. An editor may apply different rules to authors and reviewers, or tailor a policy to a particular paper. A funder may have requirements specific to a grant. Our protocol gives journals a standard way to state their rules and check an author’s ties against them. Authors can document their independence and choose how much detail to share. The current draft covers manuscript submissions. The reviewer and funder examples below show how the same approach could work in other settings.

One record, multiple policies

Suppose you received a research grant from MotMot Computing four years ago. The grant has since ended. Last year, you collaborated with researchers at Nuthatch Industries.

A possible reviewer request

An editor is handling a paper that reports environmental harm from a MotMot product. For this paper, they want peer reviewers with no ties to MotMot or its competitor, Nuthatch Industries. They could add that condition to the journal’s usual reviewer policy.

  • You’ve published your ties and kept them up to date. The editor could see the grant and the collaboration and decide whether to invite you to review.
  • You keep those ties private. You would receive a request. If you approved sharing just the result, the editor would receive yes, meaning at least one tie meets the policy. You would decide whether to share the details.
  • The relevant information is incomplete or outdated. If the available information can’t establish whether you have a matching tie, the result would be unknown. The editor could ask you to review that part of your record.

A possible funder request

A funder wants to support research on a MotMot Computing product and requires applicants to have no research funding from MotMot on the application date. Past engagement falls outside this policy.

  • You’ve published the relevant ties. With the grant’s end date and a complete, up-to-date review confirming no current MotMot funding, the funder would receive no. Your application would meet this funding condition.
  • You keep those ties private. You would receive a request. After confirming you have no current MotMot funding, you could approve a no reply. The details of your past ties would stay private.
  • The relevant information is incomplete. If it’s unclear whether any MotMot funding remains active, the answer would be unknown. The funder could ask you to review or complete that part of your record as a condition of proceeding with your application.

An author disclosure

For a submission, a journal might ask only about industry research funding or consulting work in the past two years. You could review your ties for that period and prepare a disclosure statement that matches the journal’s requirements.

Read the protocol and worked examples